If you were to start looking in to the security of WordPress plugins one thing that might quickly stand out is how often security plugins have security vulnerabilities themselves. At first glance that seems odd, but if you know a little more about those security plugins it starts to make a lot of sense.

Many security plugins are not things that someone that knows much about security would be likely to be developing. For example, despite the claims to the contrary made by security companies, their own data shows that there are not brute force attacks occurring against WordPress admin passwords. So you wouldn’t see someone that knows much about security spending time on that sort of plugin. That makes what we found with the plugin Limit Login Attempts Reloaded not all that surprising.

That plugin is described as:

Limit the number of login attempts that possible both through the normal login as well as using the auth cookies.
WordPress by default allows unlimited login attempts either through the login page or by sending special cookies. This allows passwords (or hashes) to be cracked via brute-force relatively easily.
Limit Login Attempts Reloaded blocks an Internet address from making further attempts after a specified limit on retries has been reached, making a brute-force attack difficult or impossible.

In a previous post we discussed how the plugin Limit Login Attempts, which has  2+ million active installations according to wordpress.org, contains a persistent cross-site scripting (XSS) vulnerability due to its handling of the X-Forwarded-For HTTP header. In looking into that we saw mention of Limit Login Attempts Reloaded and went to check if it was similarly vulnerable. What we found was that it was even more insecure, since unlike Limit Login Attempts, the vulnerability is exploitable without the plugin have to have a setting changed from its default (other than version 2.0.0, which required that setting changed as well). We further found that contrary to its description, it is actually incredibly easy to bypass the limit on logins attempts imposed by the plugin, so the plugin introduces a security vulnerability in exchange for incredibly porous protection against something that really isn’t a threat the average WordPress website should be worried about.

Despite all of that the plugin currently has 70,000+ active installations according to wordpress.org (by comparison the companion plugin for our service, which can help protect websites against a real threat even if not used with our service, is only used on 4,000+ websites).

By default, when there is a failed login attempt it is logged using the function notify_log(), which is located in the file /core/LimitLoginAttempts.php:

644
645
646
647
648
649
650
651
652
653
654
655
656
657
658
659
660
661
662
663
664
665
666
667
668
669
670
671
672
673
674
675
676
677
678
679
680
681
682
683
684
685
686

public function notify_log( $user_login ) {
 
	if ( ! $user_login ) {
		return;
	}
 
	$log = $option = $this->get_option( 'logged' );
	if ( ! is_array( $log ) ) {
		$log = array();
	}
	$ip = $this->get_address();
 
	/* can be written much simpler, if you do not mind php warnings */
	if ( !isset( $log[ $ip ] ) )
		$log[ $ip ] = array();
 
	if ( !isset( $log[ $ip ][ $user_login ] ) )
		$log[ $ip ][ $user_login ] = array( 'counter' => 0 );
 
	elseif ( !is_array( $log[ $ip ][ $user_login ] ) )
		$log[ $ip ][ $user_login ] = array( 
			'counter' => $log[ $ip ][ $user_login ],
		);
 
	$log[ $ip ][ $user_login ]['counter']++;
	$log[ $ip ][ $user_login ]['date'] = time();
 
	if ( isset( $_POST['woocommerce-login-nonce'] ) ) {
		$gateway = 'WooCommerce';
	} elseif ( isset( $GLOBALS['wp_xmlrpc_server'] ) && is_object( $GLOBALS['wp_xmlrpc_server'] ) ) {
		$gateway = 'XMLRPC';
	} else {
		$gateway = 'WP Login';
	}
 
	$log[ $ip ][ $user_login ]['gateway'] = $gateway;
 
	if ( $option === false ) {
		$this->add_option( 'logged', $log );
	} else {
		$this->update_option( 'logged', $log );
	}
}

The value of the IP address that gets logged comes from the function get_address():

1002
1003
1004
1005
1006
1007
1008
1009
1010
1011
1012
1013
1014
1015

public function get_address( $type_name = '' ) {
 
	if ( !empty( $_SERVER['HTTP_X_FORWARDED_FOR'] ) )
		return $_SERVER['HTTP_X_FORWARDED_FOR'];
 
	elseif ( !empty( $_SERVER['HTTP_X_SUCURI_CLIENTIP'] ) )
		return $_SERVER['HTTP_X_SUCURI_CLIENTIP'];
 
	elseif ( isset( $_SERVER['REMOTE_ADDR'] ) )
		return $_SERVER['REMOTE_ADDR'];
 
	else
		return '';
}

If the HTTP header X-Forwarded-For is included with a request that will be returned as the IP address. Since that header comes from the request, it can be set by the requester (unless it is set by a proxy between the requester and the website), so for example, malicious JavaScript code could be used as the value. The value is not sanitized before being stored as a WordPress option.

Once enough attempts have been made to cause a lockout information on that will be shown on the plugin’s admin page (/wp-admin/options-general.php?page=limit-login-attempts). The underlying code that displays does not escape the IP address value, which allows persistent cross-site scripting (XSS) to occur. The data is brought in here:

160
161

$log = $this->get_option( 'logged' );
$log = LLA_Helpers::sorted_log_by_date( $log );

Then the lock outs are split up here:

186

foreach ( $log as $date => $user_info ):

And then the IP address is output on this line:

<td class="limit-login-ip"><?php echo $user_info['ip']; ?></td>

The function get_address() is also the key to bypass the limit on login attempts, as by simply providing a different value for X-Forwarded-For with each login attempt the plugin will never see that there have multiple attempts coming from the same IP address since they will see them all as different ones. It should also be possible to lock someone else out if you knew what there IP address is, by simply sending their IP address as the value of X-Forwarded-For for repeated failed requests.

More concerning coming from a security plugin, the developer provides no way of directly contacting them. The only method that it appears you can contact is through the wordpress.org Support Forum, which would lead to moderators complaining, so we are just disclosing this (it be great if WordPress would finally fix the poor moderation of the Support Forum so we would not need to do that and so that we could go back to notifying the Plugin Directory of disclosed vulnerabilities in the current version of WordPress plugins so they don’t remain in directory, as they do now).

Proof of Concept

Attempt to log in to WordPress with the X-Forwarded-For HTTP header set to “<script>alert(document.cookie);</script>” until you are locked out. That header can be set in Chrome using the ModHeader extension.

Afterwards, when visiting the page /wp-admin/options-general.php?page=limit-login-attempts any available cookies will be shown in an alert box.

Concerned About The Security of the Plugins You Use?

Plugin Security Scorecard Grade for Limit Login Attempts Reloaded

See issues causing the plugin to get less than A+ grade